I don't care what people say, I don't even care that I hate his face, I think Roeper is a fine replacement for the late Siskel. I grew up on this show and surprisingly no one's done it better or even bothered to try. Although I do remember a Nickelodeon show where kids reviewed movies – the biggest film criticism on that show was usually that the dog catcher character was really really mean.
I don't always agree with the reviews but I appreciate the simplicity of a review show that doesn't try to appeal to the Mountain Dew demographic (yes, Henry Rollins I'm speaking to you). This is also the show that inspired me to start my blog, so it is most deserving of a spot.